Integrated Decision-making Method in Performance Evaluation and Rating of Recreational-Sports Pools

Document Type : Original Article


1 Ph.D Candidate in Sport management, Physical Education faculty, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran.

2 Sport Mangement Department, Sport Sciences Faculty, University of Isfahan

3 PhD in Sport Management, Physical Education faculty, Isfahan (Khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran.


The present study is implemented to identify indicators and to provide an optimal evaluation method in recreational-sports pools. The present study is considered practical in purpose, and survey in collecting data. Firstly, by bibliometric research and five professional experts’ interviews, 91 indicators were identified for evaluating recreational-sports pools. Secondly, in terms of 4 components or perspectives in the Balanced Scorecard, 57 indicators were established (internal processes (10 indicators), customer (22 indicators), growth and learning (19 indicators), and financial (6 indicators)), from focal group’s output which was comprised of 4 prominent professors. The structure was confirmed based on 333 individuals’ opinions in the statistical population by employing factor analysis. In order to rate the pools studied, the gray clustering analysis method was applied followed by the structure of the balanced scorecard confirmed. Principally, 20 homogenous recreational-sports pools were investigated in 15 city regions and boundaries of provinces in Isfahan, Sepahan Shahr, and Baharestan. Based on data analysis and rating of each case study, Araman, Absar, Enghelab, Morvarid, and Golsar pools were ranked first to fifth, respectively. Furthermore, the main purpose of the present study based on calculated indicators is to propose a practical method to provide an accurate evaluation of sports pools. 


Abtahi Nia, A., Mir Kazemi, S. O., & Keshti Dar, M. (2012). Optimize evaluation of sport department in
universities using a combined model by BSC, EFQM and DEA. Research in Educational Sport, 1(3),
Awadallah, E., & Allam, A. (2015). A Critique of the Balanced Scorecard as a Performance Measurement
Tool. International Journal of Business and Social Science, 6(7), 91-99.
Chiesa, V., Frattini, F., Azzarotti, V., & Manzini, R. (2008). Designing a Performance Measurement System
for the Research Activities: A Reference Framework and an Empirical Study. J. Eng Technol Manage,
25(3), 213-226.
Cleland, V., Ball, K., Hume, C., Timperio, A., Abby, C., King, A. C., & Crawford, D. (2010). Individual,
social and environmental correlates of physical activity among women living in socioeconomically
disadvantaged neighborhoods. Journal of social science & medicine, 70(1), 2011-2018. 
Daneshfard, K., Vahdani, K., & Aghaz, A. (2010). Studying the role of balanced scorecard implementation in
performance improvement of organization. Leadership and education management magazine, 4(2),
Faraji Sabokbar, H. A., Mahmoudi Meimand, H., Rahimi, S., & Shadman Roodposhti, M. (2013). The
Evaluation of Land Eco-Capability for Water Planting Using Grey Clustering Analysis. World Applied
Sciences Journal, 21(1), 142-151.
Fekete, M., & Rozenberg, I. (2014). The Practical Model of Employee Performance Evaluation. International
Conference Human Capital without Borders: Knowledge and Learning for Quality of Life, 14, 141-
Fesanghari, E., Ramezaninezhad, R., & Ghorbani, M. (2021). Introducing a Performance Appraisal Tool for
Sports Federations. Journal of Sport Management, 13(2), 473-510.
Fooladvand, M., Yarmohammadian, M. H., & Shahtalebi, S. (2015). The application strategic planning and
balance scorecard modelling in enhance of higher education. Social and Behavioral Sciences, 186,
Hariri, N., & Sarafpoor, S. (2014). Exposure Indicators for Performance Evaluation of Iranian Special Libraries
with Balanced Scorecard Approach. Journal of Knowledge Studies, 7(27), 31-42.
Honari, H., Mohammadi, L., Ghafouri, F., & Afshari, M. (2012). Application of PCA method in evaluating
the performance of sports federations Based on EFQM approaches. New Trends in Sport Management,
1(2), 19-29.
Karami, K., Salimi, M., & Soltan Hosseini, M. (2022). Performance Evaluation of Sports Boards Based on
Combinatory Model of BSC-MEA with Negative Data. Strategic studies on youth and sports, 20(54),
Ke, L., Xiaoliu, S., Zhongfu, T., & Wenyan, G. (2012). Grey Clustering Analysis Method for Overseas Energy
Project Investment Risk Decision. Systems Engineering Procedia, 3, 55-62.
Kizlik, B. (2015). Measurement, assessment, and evaluation in education. Robert Kizlik and Associates Boca
Raton, Florida, Retrieved From http/www.Adprima.Com Measurement.
Kusumawardani, R. O., & Agintiara, M. (2015). Application of Fuzzy AHP-TOPSIS Method for Decision
Making in Human Resource Manager Selection Process The Third Information Systems International
Conference, Procedia Computer Science, 72, 638-646.
Mahapatra, B., Mukherjee, K., & Bhar, C. (2015). Performance Measurement–an DEA-AHP Based Approach.
Journal of Advanced Management Science, 3(1), 26-30.
Mirfakhraddini, S. h., Peymanfar, M. H., Khatibi Aqda, A., & Ali Mohammadi, H. (2013). Evaluating the
performance of the sports organizations using the consistent BSC-TOPSIS model. Sports
Management, 5(16), 77-96.
Moch, A. (2021). Evaluation Program: Seven-A-Side Football Coaching National Paralympic Committee
(NPC) of Indonesian at ASEAN Para Games 2015 in Singapore. Journal of New Studies in Sport
Management, 2(4), 265-273.
Mohammadi, L., Honari, H., & , A., M. (2016). Performance Evaluation of Sport Federation Applying
European Foundation for Quality Management Excellence Index: Case Study (Canoeing federation).
Sport Management Studies, 8(35), 163-182.
Moodi, D., & Talebpoor, M. (2019). Application of Action and Strategic Position Assessment Matrix (SPACE
ANALYSIS) IN SPORT BUSINESS (Case Study: Swimming Pools) Applied Research in Sport
Management, 7(4), 57-66.
Naderian jahromi, M., & Akhavan, E. (2021). Identification and Evaluation of a Model for Succession in
Football Pro League of Iran Based on the Grounded Theory Approach. Journal of New Studies in Sport
Management, 2(3), 224-234.
Nasiri, S. S., & Soleymani Amiri, G. (2020). Evaluating the financial performance of investment companies
in Iran. Financial accounting and auditing studies, 3(27), 135-160.
Salimi, M., & Khodaparast, M. (2018). Presentation and Implementation of BSC-GCA Model for Performance
Appraisal and Ranking in Youth and Sport Offices. Sport Management Studies, 10(47), 109-130.
Salimi, M., & Khodaparast, M. (2019). Providing a combined model of fuzzy AHP and numerical taxonomy
analysis for sport organizational ranking and performance appraisal. International Journal of System
Assurance Engineering and Management, 10(5), 1133-1144.
Salimi, M., & Khodaparast, M. (2021). Providing the optimal method for sport places site selection based on
GIS analytic functions. Journal of Facilities Management,, 19(3), 339-357.
Salimi, M., Khodaparast, M., & Mohammadi, J. (2022). Providing a Combined Model for Sport Organizational
Ranking and Performance Appraisal in Fuzzy Space. Journal of Sport Management, 14(1), 42-67. 
Salimi, M., & Soltan Hosseini, M. (2018). Sport facilities and equipment management. Iran, Isfahan:
University of Isfahan Publishing.
Skandari Dastgiri, S., Amirtash, A., & Safania, A. (2018a). The Relationship between the Performance
Components Evaluation in the Efficiency of Sport Federations. Applied Research in Sport
Management, 6(4), 19-26.
Skandari Dastgiri, S., Amirtash, A. M., & Safania, A. M. (2018b). Performance Measurement of Selected
Iranian Sport Federations Using Data Envelopment Analysis by an Approach to Fuzzy Systems. New
Trends in Sport Management, 3 (5 (19)), 23-36.
Sorooshian, S. (2014). Study on Unbalances of the Balanced Scorecard. Applied Mathematical Sciences,,
8(84), 4163-4169.
Stas, D., Lenort, R., Wicher, P., & Holman, D. (2015). Green Transport Balanced Scorecard Model with
Analytic Network Process Support. Sustainability, 7(11), 15243-15261.
Stufflebeam, D. L., & Coryn, C. L. (2014). Evaluation theory, models, and applications: John Wiley.
Valderrama, T., García, C., Rodríguez, V. B., & Revuelta, D. (2013). Balanced scorecard and efficiency:
Design and empirical validation of a strategic map in the university by means of DEA. American
Journal of Operations Research, 3(1), 30-52.
Wu, W. H., Lin, C. T., Peng, K. H., & Huang, C. C. (2012). Applying hierarchical grey relation clustering
analysis to geographical information systems – A case study of the hospitals in Taipei City. Expert
Systems with Applications, 39(8), 7247-7254.
Zhang, T., Cheng, L., Guo, M., & Xue, W. (2016). Evaluation of electromagnetic shielding and wear ability
of metal wire composite fabric based on grey clustering analysis. The Journal of the Textile Institute,
107(1), 1-8.